see discussion overview

Related

On Yoomoot, couldn't we still ask our question, instead of editing a similar answer?

Categorised in:

I say/ask this for several reasons:
1) My answer that, for being "similar" to an already existing one, might force an edit that could disrupt the previous answer if i decide to erase parts of the answer, or if i am not counscious on that edit, etc. (forgive me if i am not understanding the practical dynamics of the answer editing process)
2) Answering "similarly" could be automatically arranged as a parallel answer to the supposedly similar already existing answer, either from text processing to make comparisons (this interests me and steers towards a personal project), or from tags, that can be compared and statiscally "counted" to see if theres a similar text with those tags (i could ellaborate on this - again considering my personal project - that some tags, even if different in words, can be the same - synonyms, related, tag network, etc.)
3) My new answer, although supposedly "similar" could bring more to the discussion if kept individually instead of merged into some other.
I see a lot of potential on this Q&A system, that could be excitingly expanded.

Forgive this text if i am missing some important point on the dynamics of Yoomoot. :) I am very interested on the subject and navigating Yoomoot is messing with my neurons..in a good way.

I'm optimistic the existing system works: if an edit disrupts the original answer the edit can be easily undone

The answer's history interface shows exactly how the answer has been edited, so any disruptive edits can easily be undone or satisfactorily resolved.

I'm optimistic the existing system works: merged answers need not lose their distinctness

Proposal no. 2 would be great, and some version of it would be very helpful even within the existing system as a way of auto-suggesting to people that an answer should be merged.
In the existing system it possibly to merge an answer with an existing answer while still keep a sense of their separateness. For example, two users MrAndrews and MsBlue could have two separate answers within the same answer simply by adding "[username] says:" before their bit. Like this:

MrAndrews says: Yes, that's a very goood idea
MsBlue says: Yes, I also think that's a good idea. My grandma did the same thing and it worked wonders for her.